Review: Kickin’ Buffalo Chicken Sandwich from Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse

Bottom Line: The Kickin’ Buffalo Chicken Sandwich from Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse is a good value and quite tasty, and it brings some heat.

Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse is an up-and-coming chain known for its New York-style pizza, Buffalo wings, burgers, and more, along with a wide selection of beers on tap. A location opened near me a couple of years ago, and it has made it to my short list of restaurants for when I decide to dine out (which is getting less frequent these days due to current prices). They have a few spicy options, including their wings, and just recently they expanded their sandwich menu with the Kickin’ Buffalo Chicken Sandwich. That comes with a fresh, hand-breaded and fried chicken breast (slathered with your choice of mild, medium, hot, or extra-hot sauce), lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, mayo, and pepper jack cheese, all held together on a brioche bun.

I previously tried their Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich, and it was decent but lacked the heat I was looking for (and I never got around to writing up a review on it). But if you get that Kickin’ Buffalo with their extra-hot sauce, it certainly brings the burn!

The breast filet is decent in size and has a good breading-to-meat ratio. The chicken is quite tender and delivers some flavor, though the crust doesn’t have much crunch because they soak it in a fair amount of sauce. That’s not necessarily a knock against it, though, because that sauce has the tang and kick you expect, and it really amps up the flavor.

The lettuce, tomato, and onions were fresh enough, but they seemed rather superfluous, and I would prefer pickles instead, as is typical for this type of sandwich. The cheese mostly fades into the background, though it does not detract from the sandwich, while the mayo adds some creaminess. As for the brioche bun, I typically find those overrated, but the bread was really fresh and helped elevate the sandwich.

How hot is the Kickin’ Buffalo Chicken Sandwich from Parry’s Pizzeria?Most importantly, this sandwich delivers some heat! I would put it above Medium on my scale and verging toward Hot, which is pretty good for a chain restaurant. And if you hold the veggies and mayo, which dilute the heat, while adding pickles, this might get all the way up to Hot on my scale.

They don’t provide calorie information for their menu items, but I can assure you that this is not diet-friendly. My guess is that it falls somewhere in the 800-calorie range, and when you include that generous portion of fries (be sure to get the Fire Fries, which have a good kick), you will be well over a thousand cals. And you know you’re going to get a beer or two (the Skyline IPA, which is exclusive to Parry’s, is a good choice), so plan some extra time in the gym the next day.

Not only is this a really good chicken sandwich, but it is also a decent value. It sells for $13.99 in my area (including the fries), which is quite good for a chain restaurant in these days of constantly escalating prices. Heck, you’re paying that much or more for some fast-food combos, and you practically have to take out a loan if you go to Five Guys or Shake Shack. So anytime you can get a decent-sized meal for under fifteen bucks at a sit-down restaurant, you’re doing okay.

As mentioned, this is a new menu item, and there is no indication that it will be heading back to Limited-Time-Only-Ville at some point. So if you’re looking for a tasty chicken sandwich with some heat and a beer or two, this is quite a good choice. But also plan another visit, because their pizzas are worth checking out as well. They are currently located in Colorado, Texas, Arizona, and Nevada, and you can check for a location near you on their website.